Researcher
I read Ryan Watkins’s piece on Pearl and came away with several questions I haven’t been able to resolve. I’m writing them down in the hope that readers who see things differently can help me understand what I’m missing.
I learned a great deal about crypto through Ryan’s early work, and I have nothing but respect for him. I can see why he and Wilson Withiam expect AI companies to adopt Pearl.
I’m less certain how the incentive to earn its coins develops into a lasting preference for holding them.
My interest in crypto has mostly been in its practical uses in finance (e.g. stablecoins, perps, tokenization, etc). I find it easier to evaluate a service when I can identify the person who needs it and the problem it solves. I have much less conviction in BTC or ZEC as money, or in crypto as a hedge against dollar debasement. Having spent a lot of my time studying apps with product-market fit, particularly Hyperliquid, I may be less receptive to an argument built around a future monetary community.
I also have no technical background in AI or GPU engineering. For this discussion, I’m willing to assume the technology delivers what its supporters expect. Earning PEARL while serving paying customers seems a sensible proposition for an AI company.
In May, Together AI offered a discount of more than 25% on one model based on the expected value of the coins it would mine. Its customers could benefit without ever owning PEARL. As Ignas observed, buying the coin gives investors no claim on the revenue those customers generate. The discount still depends on someone assigning value to the coins.
Ryan and Wilson suggest that mining could give AI operators a sense of ownership in the network. Syncracy reports that Together had sold little of what it mined, which lends some support to that view. I can imagine that participating in a network would make people more inclined to hold its currency. Even if every AI query eventually mines PEARL, as Evan Van Ness predicts, providers could also regularly sell their rewards and keep their reserves in dollars.
I would be interested in how the companies, and the people buying their coins, behave through difficult periods. Saving in an asset involves trusting it to preserve purchasing power until the money is needed. It is difficult to judge how durable that trust will be from the enthusiasm of the early participants.
Bitcoin has had years in which to accumulate evidence of that kind. Buyers returned after many many crashes, and its community continued through bitter disagreements about its future. In 2017, major businesses and mining pools backed a plan to increase block capacity, then abandoned it when they couldn’t secure enough support.
Satoshi had long since departed. My sense is that these experiences contributed to people’s willingness to trust Bitcoin, alongside its technical properties. Its origins, the absence of a founder to settle disputes, and the convictions of its early holders may account for more of its value than we can readily measure.
Bitcoin’s earliest holders had none of that history to rely on, and Pearl could develop a history of its own. Ryan and Wilson point out that a few percent of Bitcoin’s market cap would represent an excellent outcome for PEARL, even if Bitcoin remained dominant.
I understand the attraction of that possibility; on the other hand, I’m unsure how much Bitcoin’s valuation tells us about the demand available to other monetary assets. Some of that demand may depend on confidence in Bitcoin itself. If it disappeared, I wonder how many holders would seek a replacement and how many would reconsider the whole idea.
Much would depend on why it failed. A technical problem that Bitcoin couldn’t resolve might leave its holders willing to trust a different network. A loss of confidence in the ability of scarce digital assets to preserve purchasing power could affect Pearl as well. We could continue using blockchains to move dollars and trade financial assets while preferring to keep our gold in a vault.
I would still see plenty worth building in that world, although I would be sad about what we had lost. Bitcoin has meant a great deal to this industry, even to people who never fully shared its monetary ambitions.
Investigating Bitcoin’s weaknesses seems entirely reasonable to me. Treating the monetary trust it accumulated as a market already waiting for a technically stronger entrant requires an assumption I’m less comfortable making.
For now, I suspect Pearl’s best chance is in a world where Bitcoin succeeds and validates the idea that a digital asset can serve as a lasting SoV. An AI community could then build on that precedent and, over time, find its own reasons to save in PEARL.
The author of this report may have personal holdings or financial interests in assets or tokens discussed herein. However, the author affirms that no transactions have conducted using material non-public information obtained in the course of research or drafting. This report is intended solely for general information purposes and does not constitute legal, business, investment, or tax advice. It should not be used as a basis for making any investment decisions or as guidance for accounting, legal, or tax matters. Any references to specific assets or securities are made for informational purposes only and should not be construed as an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to invest. The opinions expressed herein are those of the author and may not reflect the views of any affiliated institutions, organizations, or individuals. The opinions and analyses expressed herein are subject to change without prior notice. In addition, beyond the individual disclosures included in each report, Four Pillars, may hold existing or prospective investments in some of the assets or protocols discussed herein. Furthermore, FP Validated, a division of Four Pillars, may already be operating as a node in certain networks or protocols discussed herein or may do so in the future. Please see below links in the footer for FP Validated's participating network disclosures and for broader disclosure details.



